|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 714
|
Dear All
What a strange day. Today I had my assessment for a Blue Parking Badge. I have become a recluse as my walking is now so limited and at 48 I still need a little independence, so therefore I applied for a Blue Parking Badge.
I was asked to attend a GP practice local to me but not the one I attend. I arrived and was asked to sit in a corridor. A lady came out to see me and she said she was doing the assessment. She told me that she wanted me to walk with her around the outside of the building and at the same time for me to tell her why I had applied for a blue badge. So very carefully we set off. The first hurdle was over a door step and down a ramp which I gingerly negotiated and then I told her about my RA and how it has limited my mobility, my first knee replacement in January, failing on two anti-tnf's and now waiting for my first Rituximab infusion.. I stopped a couple of times as my ankle is really playing up at the moment. We went around to the front door of the building and it took about 3 minutes in total. She then said she was a Physio by trade and that she was an independent assessor, did not have access to my medical records and would make a report to my local council about how I had walked the 100 yards and what I had told her. I would receive a letter in 10-14 days. And that was it ................
It all seemed very strange to me that they do not take into account your medical records and I really could have told her I was suffering from numerous ailments which I am not.
Has anyone else experienced similar?
Jackie xx
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 2,237 Location: nr Southampton
|
Well Im pleased you stopped a few times and hope that note went in there.
If you dont get it you can always appeal.
Jenni xxhow to be a velvet bulldoser
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member
Groups: Registered
Joined: 8/1/2010 Posts: 255 Location: hampshire
|
Many many years ago - back in the seventies-my Dad applied for a disabled parking badge. He had very bad emphasema and could only walk very short distances. he was summoned to the council offices and had to walk a long way to find the right room. It took ages as he had to keep stopping. He was refused -basically because if was able to walk to the room he didn't need it!!! Moral of this story - if you are being assessed, be very careful . Sue
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/4/2009 Posts: 1,524 Location: W. Yorkshire
|
A report in our paper about a chap who has lost a leg in a road accident and was refused a blue badge as his disability didn't have an impact on his ability to walk! You couldn't make it up could you? YES I'VE CHANGED, PAIN DOES THAT TO PEOPLE.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 8/30/2010 Posts: 507 Location: Gravesend
|
Hi Jackie , well i am afraid you will have to wait and see .. If you are on high rate mobility of DLA then you qualify automatically. I haven't come across an assessment yet , but then it is down to the Local Authority( LA) to administer it .. see HEREIt seems like it is up to criteria that are set by the individual LA. Quote from above link:- Quote:You cannot appeal against the council or Department for Transport (DfT) if you are refused a Blue Badge. However, you may ask the council to reconsider your case if you think that all the important information was not taken into account when they reached their decision.
You can also re-apply if you feel that your mobility problems have become more serious since a previous assessment. "Important Information " could be considered as the fact that the day you were assessed was a good day , and also the fact they didn't take into account medical history. However, as with all benefits, it is not the illness itself that affects your eligibility , it is the needs you have , in this case mobility needs. Surprise surprise the Blue badge scheme is also "up for consultation " and ends on the 2nd July 2011 .. more info HERERich "The difference between 'involvement' and 'commitment' is like an eggs-and-ham breakfast: the chicken was 'involved' - the pig was 'committed'."
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 714
|
Thanks for your replies and for the further information Rich.
I am not holding out much hope of getting a blue badge even though it would improve the quality of my life from being a hermit to gaining a little independence back.
There is no right to appeal so I have to abide by their decision in 10-14 days time.
Nothing ventured, nothing gained as they say.
Jackie xx
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 9/5/2010 Posts: 364 Location: mid glamorgan
|
Good luck with your badge Jackie! Ive got one and its made a big difference. Fingers crossed she will have realised how much difficulty and pain you have walking and include it in her report.. Take care love Ceri xx
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 8/30/2010 Posts: 507 Location: Gravesend
|
Jackie , you might even have passed their criteria , so perhaps the worry is for nothing . I would still ask for a reconsideration , if unsuccessful , and state what a difference it would make to your life . I would also get letters from GP (if he/she is good) , s that is information they haven't had access to. I would also consider getting your local Councillor involved , as they are not used enough ( should be able to find out who they are from your Local Authority website.It does make a difference ! Best of luck and let us know how it goes :) Rich X "The difference between 'involvement' and 'commitment' is like an eggs-and-ham breakfast: the chicken was 'involved' - the pig was 'committed'."
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 838 Location: Nottinghamshire
|
From what I am told with my council you just have to fill a form in and normally they asses you from that. I am at the moment wondering if I should apply for one, my OT keeps asking me if I have applied for one yet (have had the form since January), last time she asked and I said No she asked me why. I just feel that it's just another downward step in accepting this illness.
I have started (and I know I shouldn't) doing what I call blue badge watch. I look at someone getting out the car and walking away normally, whilst I am having problems getting out of the car and hobbling to the shop. I don't need to use a badge all the time and I wouldn't abuse it when I didn't need it, it's not in my nature to be like that. But when I am struggling I have to find a spot to park where I can get out of the car without banging my door on the car next to me. You know what I mean, the one, two, three then try to stand up. That is normally far away from the shop entrance, so I hobble down with feet and knees hurting, get the trolley, walk around the shop, even if I only want a few things I have to take the trolley back to the car, (can't carry bags because of my fingers and wrists) and then I have to walk back to the shop with the trolley to put it back in the bay, then back to the car. Not much fun in the rain.
A few weeks ago I witnessed a woman parking in the disabled bay, getting out the car with HIGH HEEL boots on, run, yes run across the car park because it was raining and yes she was displaying a blue badge..........I was not amused, standing there looking like a drowned rat!!!!!
Hope you get one.
Paula
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/4/2009 Posts: 1,524 Location: W. Yorkshire
|
I too find this abuse really annoying and I don't even HAVE a blue badge BUT sometimes the disability can be a hidden one. My hubby had one for a short period of time as he needed immediate access to his car, he isn't 'disabled' in the 'normal' sense of the word and anyone seeing us getting out of the car would probably be incensed! We don't have the badge now. YES I'VE CHANGED, PAIN DOES THAT TO PEOPLE.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 2,237 Location: nr Southampton
|
I am pretty good at stopping myself judging now with blue badges. Heart probs and things like uncontrollable crohnes when they need to be able to get into a toilet and fast, plus people who are overweight often get shouted at for laziness when actually they are full of steroids and waiting for knee replacements... all dont look anything like disabled on the outside.
I did have one occassion with a group of young lads piled into a saxo with a blue badge who were running and jumping up the street and I did question it in my mind. There was a parking inspector around and she had already flagged them and she walked off with their badge and their details so not sure what happened but it clearly wasnt theirs to use.
I have have been flagged so many times because Im clearly young with children- even with a walking stick and wheelchair- people cant see that when you are driving into the space.
I think we should all do BAY WATCH and tip the supermarket when there are people using the bays with NO BADGE. White van man is a major culprit here, with, Im sad to say, elderly folk next. Its for disabled people!
One of my bug bears is when people use these spaces, with legitimate use of badge but sit and wait while their able bodied mate leaps out and does for them. They are taking a space and I dont think thats on. But the law says its ok.
Jenni xhow to be a velvet bulldoser
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 714
|
Paula - It took me many months to pluck up the courage to apply for the blue badge. My local council form asked for my name, address and gave one line for me to right "Rheumatoid Arthritis" and this is the only information they have. That and the three minute mobilty assessment. The letter says I do not have a right to appeal.
HOWEVER, give it a go Paula. Nothing ventured, nothing gained. I went to Tesco's (there are other Supermarket's available) this morning for the first time in months. I had two things to get and I really wanted to make the effort and not send my Husband. Again I had to park at the top end of the car park away from other cars so that I could get the door wide to get out. I hobbled over the car park, stopping several times, purchased my two things in Tesco (luckily they were near to each other) and hobbled back over the car park and went home. I then spent the rest of the afternoon in bed recovering. So, yes, I will be VERY VERY upset if they turn me down with so little evidence on what my life is like living with RA.
As for the girl in high heeled boots .......... don't get me started ................
Get that form filled in.
Rich - I did ask my GP if he would support me and he said of course but he said he did not think it would do any good as our council do not take into account medical evidence. My Rheumy team have also offered support. I think if I do get turned down, then I will take your advice and contact my local councillor and get them involved. Not taking into account medical evidence is ridiculous.
Anyway as you say, hopefully the worry is for nothing and I will get a YES.
Jackie xx
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 3,157 Location: Huddersfield
|
Hi Jackie,
I fail to see how your council can assess anyone for a blue badge without taking medical history into account! Each council is a law unto themselves!
You really do deserve to get the badge and everything crossed for you,that you do get it!
Love, Doreen xx
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 9/13/2010 Posts: 786 Location: east anglia
|
hope you have heard by now about your badge,i was lucky i got mine and so glad of it,did get one iffy comment when i first used it and got some good replies from here which i wrote down and kept,my o/t etc had told me to apply and i did talk to my gp about it, but i do think its not a fair way that it is delt with ie no medical info, i get so angry as does everyone who needs it at the able bodied who abuse the card,my late husband fought for years for a badge as he could not get about much and being a large man from medication side effects walking was difficult plus other health issues and several interviews at tribunals of which are always miles away, he was awarded high d.l.a eventually and got a badge sadly he died the same year but it made his life so much easier for that short time,i so hope you have it,dorothy
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 838 Location: Nottinghamshire
|
Well since my last post I have to announce that after several months of the form sitting there, it's been filled in and sent!!!!!!!
I have really been struggling these last few months and enough is enough. I am due to have a steroid injection on Monday but because I have had a sore throat on and off for the last 6 - 8 weeks I was told by my specialist nurse to see GP to rule out an infection, she said they can't give me one if I had any sort of infection. Got an appointment with GP, sore throat ruled out but I told him how I was struggling and showed him my CRP readings in my MTX booklet, he told me I have to get something done about my Rheumatoid (I thought that sounded like I was becoming a robot). I asked if I did send off my form would he back me up. He said yes and left a note on my records. He said that my County Council (Nottingham) normally gets in touch with the GP of the applicant.
I saw my OT the following day and she's been telling me to apply for one for ages. I took the form with me and asked if I could put her name down as being the person at the hospital who I had seen during the past twelve months about my condition. There was not enough room on the form for her, the consultant, the specialist nurses, the physios and the ortotic people. She just took the form off me and before I knew where I was she had filled it all in. She put the information about her on it and she asked my questions of how RA affected my mobility and wrote down what I said adding things about RA that I would not of even thought of putting..........all true though.
I had to put my personal details on myself, I got the photographs done and it's been posted. I did ring up and ask where to send it, it wasn't clear on the letter, I asked how long it would take and was told up to 8 weeks, depending on how many applications they were dealing with. Was told that THEY would assess my mobility from what's been put on the form. I just said to the lady on the phone that if my specialist nurse says I need one, my GP agrees that I need one, my OT who I see on a regular basis told me to apply for one, how can someone at the council who knows nothing about about my medical condition and how I am, go against the medical profession, they are not medically trained and know nothing (I would think) about RA.
I think what Jackie had to do, walking around a car park is ridiculous, if they understood this illness they would know how much it can vary.
Hope Jackie gets one and I will let you know how I get on.
Paula xx
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 714
|
Paula Well done for taking the plunge. I am still waiting .................. Have been stuck in the house yet again this weekend as do not have the energy to walk. On the Telford & Wrekin form they just asked for my GP's name but apparantly do not contact him anyway unless what I said in my 3 minute assessment does not add up and they think I am not telling the truth. I was so addled at having to walk and get everything in within three minutes I am sure they are going to ask for a psych test if nothing else. I spoke to my Dad at lunchtime and he is severely disabled following several strokes years ago. He has a blue badge and has just had a letter from Stafford Council to say that they are withdrawing all blue badges from everyone unless they had high mobility care. Luckily Dad does. However, I would have no chance. I live 30 miles away from Stafford. Another postcode lottery. Keeping my fingers crossed for you (but not my toes as they hurt today) Jackie xx
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 838 Location: Nottinghamshire
|
Jackie
When you say high mobility care, due you mean the high rate of the mobility part of DLA?
Paula x
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 714
|
Paula
Sorry yes I mean the high rate of the mobility part of the DLA. I applied over twelve months ago for the lower rate but was turned down. My health has deteriorated considerably since then but now the benefits are all changing I do not know if it is even worth applying for. I do work so do not feel entirely comfortable in claiming any benefits but that's just me.
Jackie x
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 838 Location: Nottinghamshire
|
I thought that was what you meant. I have read posts on the forum before when blue badges are being discussed and others have mentioned that their council will not issue you one if you are not receiving the higher rate of DLA for mobilty. I think that is wrong, especially now that being awarded DLA is so difficult what with all these cuts etc.
Lets look at it from a different angle. A friend of mine knows a lady who is a widow, a very independent lady who's got RA. She's also from what I have been told very wealthy, she's a multi millionaire, she's got a blue badge. The need for a blue badge is not means tested and she needs one. If she lived in Stafford in order for her to have some Independence and beable to go shopping etc she would have to claim DLA, do you think she needs it? Would it be right for her to take money that she obviously doesn't need from the state when all of these benefits are being cut, I know what I think.
I have recently read two articles in the Daily Mail on line about benefits and I have read the comments that people put. There is alot of people who think that when you've got a blue badge you are claiming every benefit going, even your car's been given to you. This bothers me alot, I am not at present claiming DLA or anything else. It worries me that if I get a blue badge people will and think the same about me.
Paula xx
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member  Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/3/2009 Posts: 714
|
Paula
The sole reason I have applied for a blue badge is so that I can have back some of my independence outside of work.
At the moment I go to work (where I can park right outside) and I come home. By going to work I do not think I should claim benefits even if I were entitled to them. I was encourage to apply for DLA when I was first diagnosed but felt very uncomfortable about it. I did not qualify at that point. All I want to do is to be able to go to the bank or chemist or supermarket on my own and hopefully park relatively near so that I do not have to bother my long suffering Husband yet again. To do this will keep me away from depression which will keep me in work so that I do not have to claim benefits. You can see how much I am hoping that I get this blue badge and how much it will benefit my family, my workplace and the benefits people. SO IF I GET MY BLUE BADGE AND I AM JUDGED WOE BETIDE THE JUDGER.
I think the blue badge scheme needs a radical overhaul. Yet again the right facts are not sought about an individual person before a decision is made which can have a dramatic impact on their life.
I am holding my breath for both of us.
Jackie xx
|
|
|
|